Monday, March 5, 2012

Searching for QB #1

Without a doubt, the most glaring question mark facing the Aggies inaugural SEC starting lineup is an important one: the starting quarterback. While a top notch quarterback doesn’t guarantee glory (look what LSU did with their QB’s), it is widely accepted as the most important and engaging position on the team. It not only requires a distinct skill set (arm strength, accuracy, speed), but also an uncanny ability to lead, motivate, and inspire. The intangibles are often just as important as the physical skills (see Timothy Richard Tebow).

That is why I am here to give the everyday Aggie fan a quick “rundown” of the three men who will be competing for the job. I am by no means a scout, and have honestly only read the breakdowns and watched the highlight videos (note they are highlight videos, not lowlight videos, so I’m not crowning any of these men as future superstars just yet). I have provided a solid amount of scouting information from educated individuals who have watched them play, in addition to a few gut instincts that I have formulated. From everything I have gathered the spot is relatively wide open going into spring practice.

Let’s begin with a physical breakdown of our three men (with their respective rivals rankings coming out of high school:

Jameill Showers: 3 Star on Rivals, #27 Pro Style QB (2010)
6’2’’ 219 lbs (6’1’’ 200 lbs out of high school)
4.62 Forty time, 4.25 Shuttle, 33 Inches (coming out of high school)

Johnny Manziel: 3 Star on Rivals, #14 Dual Threat QB (2011)
6’1’’ 200 lbs (6’1’’ 193 lbs out of high school)
4.53 Forty Time, 3.98 Shuttle, 31 inch vertical (coming out of high school)

Matt Davis: 4 Star on Rivals, #3 Dual Threat QB (2012)
6’2’’ 202 lbs (via
4.4 Forty Time, 4.02 Shuttle, 35 inch vertical (coming out of high school)

Breakdown: Honestly, this is just a primer of what these men have to offer. Manziel is likely the smallest of the three (if only by a hair), Showers has had the benefit of two years in a college weight room, and Davis obviously has the physical frame to add some muscle. As far as speed and quickness, they all possess the ability to run like a tailback, with Manziel likely being the shiftiest (corresponds with most scouting reports) and Davis having the best straight-line speed.

Now how do these men stack up against each other and who has the inside position on winning the starting gig? Let’s begin with the fact that Jameill Showers served as the primary backup this season. Now that doesn’t say much in direct comparison with Manziel and Davis given that Manziel was redshirted and Davis was still in high school, but it certainly doesn’t hurt Shower’s case. He obviously has more collegiate practices under his belt, more time in the weight room, more time in the film room, and more time with our former QB1 Ryan Tannehill. Those aspects help his cause, but to be honest, in my unprofessional opinion the optimism stops there in the pro-Shower’s corner. I am too intrigued by the next two men on the list.

Let’s continue this discussion with “the gamer” Johnny Manziel. His intangibles, leadership, and sneaky speed have already earned him countless educated Aggie supporters. I have read rave reviews on him describing him as “a magician with the ball” and “a truly gifted athlete.” He also has some similarities to Ryan Tannehill as he played a bit of receiver early on in high school. Moral of the story, this kid overachieves as if it was his full time job. It’s hard to go against such accolades.

Last, but not least, we have the youngest and most intriguing of the three (and not just because he was the most touted coming out of high school). Matt Davis, the creator of the AggSwagg movement (read Trey Bahney’s previous write-up), wants nothing more in life than to lead Texas A&M University to success. An attitude like that is contagious. And an attitude like that is what I want see in the Aggie huddle. The charisma is there; he may have recruited harder for Texas A&M than some of the coaches. And we haven’t even begun to discuss his physical gifts. The numbers show his speed, but it is his ability to throw on the run that excites me the most. Any athlete playing quarterback can scramble for positive yardage, but a great quarterback keeps his eyes downfield and trades the 8 yard gain on the ground for the 38 yard gain through the air. College football is the ideal place to make something out of nothing when the pocket collapses, and that could very well end up being Davis’ forte on the gridiron.

If you were once uninformed of the impending Aggie quarterback battle… well you may now rightfully consider yourself, “adequately informed”. With spring practice right around the corner, the situation is far from settled and a decision likely won’t be made until next fall, but the battle is on. And if I had to roll the dice at this particular moment, I would go with Matt Davis. I think the benefit of getting to College Station a semester earlier to attend spring drills might just end up being the deciding factor for him.

Maybe I am just brain-washed by the Swagg.


  1. BESCo91 - TexAgs PosterMarch 6, 2012 at 1:24 PM

    I just read your 5 March 'QB Battle' piece.
    What about Joekel? I am pretty sure that Sumlin recruited both Showers & Joekel while he was at UH.
    I see a 3 man race between Showers, Joekel, and Manziel.
    I think Davis will redshirt this soason (2012).

    NO IDEA who the 2012 QB ends up being.....and I don't think 'QB1' will be decided until halfway through Fall Camp.

    1. I did indeed leave out Joeckel and as of now that looks to be a mistake as he could be well suited for Sumlin's quick strike passing attack. While Davis could redshirt, I feel as if his skill and determination will keep him near the field. Very excited to see who comes out on top.

  2. I now feel adequately informed! Hooray!

  3. I think AggSwagg got in your decision cycle.

    Johnny Manziel didn't become a Parade All American by accident (regardless of Rivals "Stars"). Anyone that saw him play in last year's M&W game probably left wondering if Manziel would beat out Tannehill.

    May the best QB win, but I'm betting on Johnny Football.

  4. The be the best part of this QB battle? Everyone has their own good opinion, and every opinion could turn out right.